Jewelers have always had access to the widest array of astounding metals, which would often be used for the same purpose. Wedding bands, engagement rings, earrings, and other accessories can all be made from different materials. There is no limit.
But there are a trusty few that always take the lead.
White Gold vs Yellow Gold vs Rose Gold vs Platinum – which will it be?
At DMNDS, we understand that choosing the right composite for your jewelry can be difficult. In order to solve this problem, we decided to help you narrow down your decision by writing this in-depth article comparing the most popular metals used.
At A Glance
Rose gold is affordable but rare, looks great in the sun and is always trending.
Yellow gold goes well with most skin tones, easy to maintain and is hypoallergenic.
White gold is durable, cheap and matches well with fair skin tones.
Platinum is the most durable, most expensive and most luxurious of the metals.
White Gold – Shine Your Light On Me
White gold is one of the most distinct and attractive gold alloys available, especially if you are looking to have your jewelry stand out in the midst of summertime. The special combination of metals is very reflective – so make sure to wear your sunglasses.
The alloy comes in a variety of Karat weights, such as – 24K, 18K, 14K, and 10K. A “Karat” is an identifier measuring the quality and fineness of precious metals, gems, and stones.
The gold itself is a combination alloy of a variety of white metals, like silver, palladium, and nickel – mixed in with pure gold. In most cases, white gold is coated in rhodium, which is a chemically inert transition metal. But other metals are used with a selected ratio, dependent on the expected Karat weight.
The value of the gold is stringent upon the Karat weight and the actual amount of metal that was used during the creation of the jewelry piece. However, you can assume that you will pay extra for the design, specialist labor – so on and so forth.
The Case For White Gold
- The white gold alloy is credibly more affordable than Platinum.
- The finished product is often durable and resistant to wear & tear.
- White gold looks best when matched with diamonds of a lighter complexion.
- It goes well with rosy and fair skin tones.
- It is one of the most popular choices for wedding bands and engagement rings.
- It must be maintained and dipped every couple of years.
- The presence of Nickel in the alloy mix is most likely to cause an allergic reaction in some.
- White Gold is often mistaken for other “white” metals, such as Sterling Silver.
Yellow Gold – The King of Relationships
When it comes to relationships, yellow gold is king. It is the #1 material used for the creation process of most engagement rings and wedding bands.
In order to get the signature gold tint and retain the chemical integrity, pure gold is mixed with a range of other alloy metals, such as Copper and Zinc. When you ask somebody what color is gold – you’ll most likely hear that it is yellow.
Which further proves how widespread this type of gold really is.
Much like other types of gold, the higher the Karat weight, the higher the content of pure gold is. However, this is not without precedent. More gold = less durability. Therefore, a median of 14K or 18K is the best option for any sort of ring that requires some size or design manipulation.
The Case For Yellow Gold
- Yellow gold is the purest in color density.
- It is the easiest to maintain and upkeep in quality.
- It still holds to be the most hypoallergenic of the golds.
- It can be simply manipulated to any form, shape or size.
- Goes well with the darker skin tones.
- Does not need to be used with high color grade diamonds, because of the contrast.
- The gold has to be regularly polished and cleaned to prevent degradation.
- It is expected to show signs of wear and tear over time.
- It is not the most ideal type of gold for light skin tones.
Rose Gold – Fierce Like A Ruby
If you are looking to be trendy, receive compliments and save money – rose gold should be on your list of next purchases. Rose gold is pure gold mixed with silver and a range of copper alloys.
The combination of the three provides that signature reddish-tint that we all love to see on our phones and watches.
Beyond the color structure, the alloys that are used help strengthen and improve the durability of the material. The more copper used, the redder it gets which coincidentally equals increased durability.
Rose gold comes in a multitude of tones, ranging from light pinks to dark reds.
The Case For Rose Gold
- It is great for both men and women – fancy befits fancy.
- The color is very aesthetically appealing and attractive.
- Rose gold is quite affordable due to the alloy mixture.
- It is the most durable of the gold types.
- Goes well with any skin tone.
- It is definitely not hypoallergenic.
- It is not readily available, despite its affordability and popularity.
- It is harder to manipulate and mold because of the alloy density.
- Can drown other colors out, due to color clashing.
Platinum – Hard As A Stone, More Expensive Than Gold
Platinum is the unique outlier metal. It has a negligible alloy mix and is naturally white like the frost. Visually, platinum and white gold are nearly identical.
And if you care to maintain and polish it using the appropriate methods, it shall retain its original integrity and luxury for many years to come.
In all cases, platinum is more expensive than any gold type. The pound for pound cost differs greatly. The price itself is stringent upon various factors, like the vendor, the quantity of platinum used and the design/style of jewelry.
Platinum tends to look the greatest with lighter skin tones. So if you are looking to buy some platinum jewelry, make sure to check out these pros and cons.
The Case For Platinum
- Fully hypoallergenic – rub it in all you want.
- Much more rare than any gold type.
- It is the most durable of metals listed in this article.
- It looks best when used by people with fair skin tones.
- It is often used to embellish status and prestige over others.
- It is overwhelmingly more expensive than any gold type.
- You can expect the color to dull and show signs of casual wear and tear.
- It requires regular maintenance, which in fact strips away the platinum.
- Color fading is natural and unavoidable.
The Frost Battle: White Gold vs Platinum
When it comes to platinum and white gold – we have established that they are identical in color. However, what we didn’t speak of is their composition.
If white gold consists of a primarily varying mixture of alloy metals, like copper, nickel, and zinc. Platinum, on the other hand, is always expected to consists of a 95%+ original composition with a negligible consistency of silver and rhodium.
Considering, the high density of original material – jewelry vendors raise the prices for platinum pieces, as large quantities of platinum are required for their initial creation.
A “Price” Comparison
At this point, you can safely presume that platinum is overall more expensive than white gold, despite their prices ranging within the same scale on a per gram basis.
But like most things in life, demand and supply determine the finite and final price for the metal used in the jewelry piece.
Is White Gold Worse Than Platinum?
Of course not. Unless you are one of the people who buy jewelry to go from pawnshop to pawnshop showing off how special they are.
Nonetheless, you should always keep in mind, that both metals are identical in color and primarily differ in the alloy composition.
If you really think about it, white gold is the clear winner.
As it is cheaper, it can be customized for durability and presents the same visual qualities that platinum does. Besides that, white gold does not require regular maintenance, which in the end only worsens the quality of the material, and prevents the retention of its original integrity.
The Crimson Battle: Red Gold vs Rose Gold vs Pink Gold
Red gold, rose gold and pink gold are practically the same, except for minor variability in composition, which is responsible for the degree to which the gold has a red tint.
As all of the “roses” are based on a 3/4 gold and 1/4 silver/copper alloy ratio. Depending on the percentage of silver and copper, the tint changes. If copper is dominant within the composite, the darker the gold tint becomes.
Mixing pure gold with silver and copper is also responsible for the increased durability and resistance to stress.
When purchasing a rose gold piece, you will find that vendors will often use the names interchangeably without precedence.
Rose is red. Red is rose. Pink is red. Rose is pink. You get the point.
Consider This Before You Make A Decision
Now hold on a second. As we have reviewed and compared the various types of gold and even platinum – we are far from done.
So before you go and make a decision that you might regret – read through this part and consider this:
As people, we are bound to have a preference. Jewelry is the most personal expression of our inner creativity. Considering that, we take care and put thought into choosing the right pieces.
As metal composites come with varying characteristics – it is important to consider the size, design, and color correspondence that will make your jewelry stand out.
Make jewelry your own – let it be a reminder of who you are, what you want to be and what you’ve always been. If you want to be bright and energetic, consider some color. If you want something more traditional, go with the whites.
Stone, Gem, Pearl Types
When choosing the right type of gold alloy or metal composite for your jewelry, you should also be thinking of the color and type of stones that you will be using.
Unless you want a simple and bland ring (which can also look astounding) – you probably want to use a couple of gems or stones.
A colorful selection of diamonds will always look best with the deeper yellow tints of gold. Whereas, very distinct stones will look the finest with the whites.
However, in the end – it is up to you. So mix and match until you are satisfied.
If you are an active person, you probably know that it is quite easy to forget about your jewelry in the first place.
If you are into sports or any strenuous activity that involves movement, you probably want to get a metal composite or gold alloy that is durable and resistant to stress.
Yellow gold is out of the question, as it is highly malleable and prone to poor longevity. You are better off with the gorgeous rose and white golds.
When choosing the right type of gold or metal composite for your jewelry, you are bound to spend some money.
In order to stay satisfied with your decision – it is always better to do the necessary research that will prevent you from being stuck with a bill for thousands of dollars.
The prices can vary depending on multiple factors, so make sure to check out our other educational articles.
Design and Style
If you are buying jewelry for yourself, you most likely want to stand out and others to notice. If that’s the case – you can never go wrong with the current trends. Rose gold composites are always in and are guaranteed to attract the attention of others.
But if trends don’t matter to you and you are a free soul – you’ll do just as well, if not better with lighter tones, such as the white golds or platinum.
Keep in mind – that it is important to consider the density of the composite, as that will have an effect on whether or not you can manipulate the material into a certain shape or form that you have in mind.
Choosing the right alloy mix and metal composite is certainly based on personal preference, styling options, and lifestyle. Nonetheless, it is most helpful to consider the upsides and downsides to each and every option, as they all differ in price, composition, and characteristics.
If platinum is practically identical to white gold in visual correspondence but is significantly more expensive – you should probably consider doing more research, in order to avoid underwhelming emotions.
In the end, if you are looking to spend money on jewelry – we recommend you use your budget on quality diamond stones [possible place for internal link] or colorful gems that will make any composite stand out.
If you are looking to customize a perfect jewelry piece, read through our series of articles that will give you an in-depth overview of making it a reality. Learn how to find the highest quality stones. Discover how to mix and match colors for optimal aesthetics. Establish your character and turn heads with competence in jewelry.